Coastal Farmhouse

After decades of building for others, the McElmurrys build a home for themselves that combines modern, traditional and coastal features perfect for easy Fairhope living

Exterior paint color: Sherwin Williams Pure White, Trim color: Sherwin Williams Homburg Gray

Not many people can say they’ve entered into retirement plans early. And while Mike and Tamatha McElmurry are hardly retired, they did stumble upon their retirement dream lot, and upon it, they built a dream home.

Ten years ago, the couple was visiting some dear friends on School Street in Fairhope when they spotted the lot. It had a dilapidated house on it and seemed to have been forgotten. So they approached the owner and tried to purchase it, but the owner politely refused. A few years later, the property went up for sale, and the McElmurrys leapt at the option, placing a blind offer on it amidst five others. “We didn’t think it was going to happen for us, but he accepted our offer, ” Tamatha recalls.

Porch swing: Local furniture maker Luke Phillips produces custom swinging beds that are a favorite for coastal homes. Tip: He is opening a new store in Fairhope later this year at a retail and event development that the McElmurrys are designing. Stay tuned! Custom swing • $1, 000 – $2, 400

​Tamatha began selling real estate in 1996, the same year Mike got his start in home building. She laughs, “This is when I took on the role of designer/decorator as my ‘hobby.’” The pair work together on all their building projects, with Tamatha designing the space and finishes while Mike handled the build. They drew from this depth of experience to build their own home, a process that is full of both highs and lows. “After building for 20 years, we have learned to take the challenges in stride, ” Mike says.

- Sponsors -

The couple envisioned a modernized coastal cottage that would look like it belonged in downtown Fairhope and  near the Bay. “Mike and I collaborated on each room to incorporate all the natural, traditional and modern elements we envisioned, ” Tamatha says. Mike adds, “We wanted an open concept that would flow well for dining and entertaining.” They also wanted outdoor living areas that would serve them just as well when their two teenage daughters would soon leave for college.

After the couple designed the layout, Tamatha began work on the details and decor, a job right up her alley; her specialties are lighting, color palette, cabinet design and flooring. “I really had fun with this house, ” she says. “I subscribe to the concept of a ‘collected home.’ I do not match elements; I design to have complementary elements.” For example, Tamatha collected her coveted Persian rugs 20 years ago through online auctions and says she will never part with them. “They are a part of my home now, and I love how they bring a unique and artful element wherever they are used.”

Tamatha cooks and entertains often, and the layout is perfect for having lots of people gathered around so she can be a part of the conversation. “Right now during football season, I can keep up with the food and still be right in the middle of the action in the living room.”

Most afternoons you’ll find the girls on the porch napping or working on homework and at night hanging out there with friends. As Tamatha simply says, “We like it that way.” But while the couple might soon be empty nesters, they’ll still have a bit of company at home. Vinny Barbarino, a little Shih Tzu with a big attitude, and Baylor the snuggly Goldendoodle will get to enjoy the beautiful new home for years to come.

Paint color: Sherwin Williams Pure White. Cow hide: Tamatha’s family brought her a cowhide from Colorado as a surprise. You can find one locally at Sarah B. Atchison’s • Colors and prices vary

Island and bar paint color: Sherwin Williams Oyster Bay. Backsplash: One-inch planed driftwood tiles make a unique backsplash that is just begging to be touched. RF Henry Driftwood Tile • Jubilee Flooring • $22 per sq ft


Bar Pulls: Oversized bar pulls make a strong statement on simple shaker cabinetry. Emtek 12” stainless steel bar pulls • Rayford & Associates • $17. Kitchen Pendant Lights: Tamatha often designs her own light fixtures from reclaimed wood, scrap metal and artful objects. But you can score her kitchen fixtures online. Possini euro brushed nickel chandelier • Lamps Plus • $799

ABOVE “We wanted an art gallery look so that our original art would have a place to shine.” – Homeowner Tamatha McElmurry on her white walls


Paint color: Sherwin Williams Pure White. Chandelier: Natural beads in a grand silhouette are an interesting touch in the bath. Similar to the McElmurry’s – Ro Sham Beaux 24” Quartz fixture • Malouf Furniture & Design • $2395. Bathroom Tile: Wood-look tile in Stormy Gray • Jubilee Flooring & Decorating • $5 per sq ft.

Fire Pit: Tamatha scored this custom steel fire pit at Fairhope Arts and Crafts Festival. Bonus: If you missed the festival, they are sold online! S&S Fire pits 36” elliptical on legs • $585


Get the best of Mobile delivered to your inbox

Be the first to know about local events, home tours, restaurant reviews and more!